I'm not sure. Maybe I was hoping for a bit more of a link to 1913 NY but except for some of the street names it felt very generic. Instead it is a list of names, places, events, etc. set up in a d6 random list. So you can have (6) Tommy from (3) East Side with (1) No Family and (1) Rum running. I think I was hopping for more color description of the city, life, street scenes.
[3 of 5 Stars!]