This is the last of the City States by Bob Bledsaw. Judges Guild retreated from the hexagon system used by The City-State of the World Emporer, returning to the City-State of the Invincible Overlord's style of mapping. It comes off a bit more rigid and more mechanical looking than CSotIO, but seems to have retained much the same high-fantasy vibe.
If you are wondering why it didn't do as well or have as much fan-fare as the previous entries, it could be that most JG fans would have recognized TARANTIS as a campaign region and perhaps thought that this detailed a wilderness map. It was also a time when the RPG publishing industry was getting more glossy, more professional, and there was no matching change in quality or quality control at Judges Guild.
However, there is a solid City State effort here, and it is more satisfying than CSotWE and perhaps a bit less inspired than CSotIO. If you need or collect RPG cities, this is a good one and well worth a look.
The scan quality is not that great, with a fair amount of grey-scale greys in the text. The text itself is readable, but if it is has an OCR element, it is locked from use - you cannot copy text. All in all, passable, but annoyingly limited.
The map is, well, functional. I recalled how these maps were printed - brown ink on tan paper - and the quality is what it is, which is usable, but not very pretty, with vast areas around the city being a blight.
Me, I am quite happy to have it and give it 4 of 5 stars. However, if I were not a Judges Guild fan, it would be at least 1 star lower.
|