It's awfully hard to argue with "free," and I really like quite a few of LPJ Design's products, but I just don't see myself using these cards. In summary, the cards are too big, try to incorporate too many details, and don't match my own needs and expectations very well.
For more details, read on.
These initiative cards try to do too much in too small a space. As another reviewer wrote, these quarter-sheets are not so much cards as miniature character sheets. But as miniature character sheets, they won't serve you well for very long. With only three lines for each category of power (at-will, encounter, daily, and utility), you'll run out of space on the card by the time you reach the paragon tier. There's no room for feats or class abilities, so the information is seriously incomplete if the cards are trying to be miniature character sheets.
Thing is, being a miniature character sheet isn't a good goal for an initiative card. Personally, I favor a minimalist approach to DM bookkeeping, and this product takes a different tack. In the middle of combat, I as a DM don't need to see all the numbers for the characters' ability scores, a list of their powers, their attack strings, and so on. All I really need is a name and an initiative number, and maybe some of the information included in the left-hand column on the LPJ initiative cards (current hp, use of second wind, and most especially, conditions and passive insight/perception)--but in my own games, I use plastic/acrylic tokens to represent conditions, death saves, magic item uses, and so on, and I let the PCs handle the rest of their own bookkeeping.
I should "come clean" and state that I game with a laptop and have an initiative tracking tool that serves me just fine. I have tried to write this review from the perspective of a DM actually seeking to use initiative cards to track combat.
|