Really nice mix between a toolbox and a setting - the book is packed with very flavourful and detailed tables and procedures to make an island hopping game in a particular type of flooded world, creating seas with their own currents, islands, factions, Leviathans, and Tyrants. If you've read other books and zines by Lazy Litch you'll recognise the weird/dark fantasy atmosphere, but this is more extensive and suitable for a whole campaign, though I think you could also use it for areas of an existing world if they were sufficiently remote.

Disappointing. The concept is interesting. The artwork and writing are both excellent, but the content is just a bit lacking. It's presented as a toolkit, and that's really all you get, a box of tools. References are made to different armor types and currency, but never discussed. An insect-centered class is provided with no other reference to it or insects. It just feels rushed and un-finished. Nothing about classes or races (other than sea elves, and the odd entomologist), nothing about society, cultures, etc. It does provide an interesting mechanism for generating a wavecrawl, but it is very specific to the Wind Wraith world concept that it would be a bit of work to make it useful under a different setting. The ship-as-character concept is cool, and the ship-to-ship combat rules are useful.