There are some really good ideas in here, and the mechanics seem pretty solid. Unfortunately, it was advertised as a 5E and A5E supplement, and it is definitely NOT 5E compatible. At first I was seeing A5E language and figuring that I could do conversions on my own (although I didn't want to). However, soon it became obvious that the bulk of the player-facing material simply could not be converted. Paranormal Power uses mechanics that have no 5E equivalent: rattled, expertise dice, combat traditions, exertion, etc.
I like a lot of the content, I really do. I just wouldn’t have backed it if it were billed as an A5E only supplement. And it clearly is.
UPDATE: I reviewed this and complained that it was more A5E than 5E, giving it 3 stars. The publisher responded with an acknowledgment that it was A5E based and included some pretty comprehensive suggestion on how to make it backwards compatible to fit better with 5E. I appreciated that a lot and revised my rating to 4 stars. Were those suggestions to be included in the PDF, preferably in the main text but even as an appendix, I would give it 5 stars. If you primarily play A5E or are very comfortable converting A5E to 5E, buy this product!
|