Not only is this an excellent standalone product that you could drop into any ongoing campaign, but it is stuffed full of atmosphere and invention.

The inclusion of Gnomes as a playable race would get this 4 stars on its own, the addition of Pub Games would probably get it another start, but then that would leave me no stars to give to the actual sceanarios. Oh, the perils of min-maxing! This is a great book that revitalises many classic sceanrios for 4e, bringing them right up to date and knocking out a few small issues along the way. There are a few wee errors which are being polished out as we read this and will not be resent in the print form. More great work by Andy and Co.