Midnight is a dark setting but the dark side is so heavy that sometimes it's a bit hard to believe. Everything is dark, nobody is happy, everybody is starving in a gloomy land, being an elf or a dwarf means you'll be killed on sight ... I guess I was waiting for something maybe more subtle, with an evil that could seduce people to make them believe that Izrador is the right way (like in the video game Tyranny) but here Izrador is just an invincible force of evil that tortures, uses and oppresses people. That would make me think if I was in this world "no food, no hope, no other gods ? why bother living ? "
The rules also are very light and it's a big problem. We're supposed to create characters that can fight the Shadow but without noticeable armor or weapons (they are forbidden) and without flashy magic. The rules won't help : no subclasses that would provide "unarmored defense", brawling skills (you have to pay a feat for this), discreet magic or some capacities that can help to fight back, ... Or maybe the intention was to play only in wilderness where you will have to hit-and-run all your life ? no urban adventures, hidden among the population ? Also some feats are a bit weird like "You have advantage on Strength (Athletics) checks to grapple a creature who cannot see you" which is already the case in the basic rules ... The rest is good, the book is well-written, the images are inspiring, the forces of shadow are ennemies your players will hate with a passion, breaking a black mirror is already an awesome quest plot ... hence the 3/5

Very useful, it brings a lot of colors to parts of the game that usually don't shine. Thanks !

Finally a way to live some adventures in Golarion without spending hours in the boring fights created by the original Pathfinder system. The book is promising and the class edges are perfect to emulate the usual classes quickly. The transposition is of course not perfect though, so better warn your players that if your group decide to switch to SW, you'll have a little bit of changes here and there. Otherwise, the book is pretty, well written, you don't need the SWADE rulebook to start an adventure. One or two (subjective) regrets though : the bestiary is very thin, no Chimera, no Hydra, only the basic of the basics (you'll need the Pathfinder® for Savage Worlds Bestiary for more) and the iconic classes as the Summoner or the Magus are not included. But if your group is used to the terrible "I miss ... He misses ... I miss again .. He hits, 7 damage, 54 hit points left.", the SW adaptation can bring a very refreshing dynamism and energy to your fights scenes.

Tons of options that add flavor to every classes. My table was definitely looking for more ways to twist the classes of the core rulebook and Dark Alleys filled every expectations we had.