Well, I must admit I expected and wanted more out of this product. I don't mind too much the lore changes; but I do the following issues:

-Poor proofreading of the product (in just a quick glange I found lot of typos, reference to 3.5 rules (the outsider creature type) and even reference to setting elements who were not ported to this version)

-While I do think that the 3.5 version had really TOO MUCH specific rules, this has too FEW. You just can't have the feeling of Midnight with standard 5e rules. No changes to the rest mechanics, no new subclasses, just a few backgrounds and feats. Heroic Paths are not even that great considering they just are feat trees and some are way too powerful (I'm looking at you, Channeler), or way too weak.

I did not want ALL the rules from the previous edition, but at least the could have bothered to convert Charms (since they mentioned many times in the book), maybe create a fighter subclass for the old Defender class or a spell-less ranger variant, some new feats for the midnight specific weapons and some more.

While I'm disappointed by this, the artwork is great, but I can't go over 3 stars. I just hope that Edge plans to release a supplement to fix the rules lacking from this one.

The Rules are great, tho the layout is a mess really. It's all confused from page 1 index to the index of the book. And that's a shame really. I really wish the author could fix this so that this book can really be the beginning of a new era for this Setting.

Excellent scan, awesome book. A must have for the post-Ashes period.

The book is awesome, but i'm still waiting for a new scan, cause the present one is horrible.

What is this low quality jpg art? it seems ripped off from old pdfs of the books, there are even cut pieces of art and in some other there is a chunk of the book's layout. They are inferior in every way compared to the first batch of art that was released

The new scans are amazing. The cropping is fine, the maps are there, Bookmarks are present and the quality of the pages is just perfect.

The Content is useful, but I wished it was more than a mere conversion of the over complicated system created for Pathfinder. I would a more streamlined version and one that actually uses this edition philosophy. The price of the pdf is too high for the page count.

the quality of teh scan is poor. The product is good but WotC should try harder to provide REAL High Quality Scans if they want us to pay for them.

The quality of the scan is superb, except for the cover and back cover. they are too dark (fix this if you can). Overall a great product for a great setting.

PDF di buona qualita, ma manca di segnalibri il che abbassa la qualità del prodotto. Inoltre non sono stati corretti proprio tutti gli errori segnaliti.