I have fond memories of some of the earlier Xanth novels. I worship Terry Pratchett as a minor deity. All of which is just a long-winded way of saying that I like humorous fantasy. So the promises made by books like The Pun is Mightier Than the Sword attract me like a moth to the flame.
Not that everything in the book is slapstick, or even funny for that matter. The feats in particular are presented as rather standard fare, with an effect adapted from the name. I'd be at a loss if asked to explain how some of them actually work, and you may not always agree with what effect the writers have assigned to a given saying, but they're all presented as normal feats.
The spells provide us with a bit more in the silliness department. It's also here that we encounter some sayings which are a little more modern and culture specific. All Your Base Are Belong to Us is a perfect example; it did certainly seem to catch on widely, but the actual audience was fairly limited to internet/geek culture. There's nothing wrong with this, but for gamers of more recent vintage, among others, might miss the references.
Many of the spells are both amusing and useful. High on Life ranks among my personal favorites, as if Kentucky Fried. As for Light as a Feather... let's just say that the other half of that particularly saying is missing from the spell lists.
Chapter three is given over to items. Here I was a bit disappointed with the jury rig, as they just limited it to traps rather than making it something that applied to all devices. The rest of the chapter features such items as the slapstick, the uglystick and just to prove everyone wrong ? the free lunch.
There are four new prestige classes ? the all around handy jack of all trades, the not always so funny jokesmith, the spit and polished knight in shining armor, and the proverbial proverbial. Some of these have fairly powerful abilities; particularly the ability of the jack of all trades to stack prestige class levels to class levels for a number of class abilities.
As a bonus, a brief appendix provides information on a few spells from two of the publisher's other products.
I didn't always agree with the writer's interpretations of a given saying. I also would have liked a little more slapstick to some of the selections, but at the same time that lack of outright goofiness makes the product usable in a wider variety of games.<br><br>
<b>LIKED</b>: Lots of fun new toys.
Nature's Calling.
For such a short product, it's well bookmarked and has a hyperlinked table of contents.<br><br><b>DISLIKED</b>: The cover of the print version is just the cover for the screen version turned grayscale ? which isn't all that printer friendly.
Some of the feats just seemed inexplicable.<br><br><b>QUALITY</b>: Excellent<br><br><b>VALUE</b>: Very Satisfied<br>
|