DriveThruRPG.com
Browse Categories
$ to $















Back
pixel_trans.gif
Tall Tales BX Wild West RPG $7.99 $1.99
Average Rating:4.3 / 5
Ratings Reviews Total
6 1
4 1
3 0
0 0
0 0
Tall Tales BX Wild West RPG
Click to view
You must be logged in to rate this
pixel_trans.gif
Tall Tales BX Wild West RPG
Publisher: Mark Hunt
by Brent W. [Verified Purchaser]
Date Added: 09/21/2021 07:54:16

Mark Hunt has found his niche in the gaming industry by making retro-clones of the the 1981 Basic Dungeons & Dragons to fit other genres, notably his take on TSR's old GangBusters, but also the western genre in his game - and the subject of this review - Tall Tales.

As a retro clone, it has the usual 6 Abilities (e.g. Strength and Wisdom), and not much has changed there. There are 6 initial classes to choose from, and these classes are a curious mix. They are all genre appropriate, but the inclusion of 2 classes over perhaps more the more genre appropriate staples is a little head-scratching and has me confused over what kind of game Mr. Hunt envisioned.

To be precise, there are 4 classes that are practically a given for an RPG of western flare: Gunslinger (filling the role of fighter), Desperado (filling the role of thief), Mountain Man (basically a Ranger from AD&D complete with animal side-kick), and Brave (which despite the name is closer to a B/X cleric than a warrior) which is nice nod to the American Indian. A lot of other games shy away from their inclusion in character choices. The other two classes are perplexing.

One is Singing Cowboy, fulfilling the function of a AD&D bard, but with the addition of horse side-kick which able to perform minor tricks. Campfire songs were a thing, but the inclusion of the wonder-horse draws obvious parallels to Gene Autry and Roy Rogers. This inclusion of the Singing Cowboy feels more like parody than a serious inclusion. The other class is Snake Oil Salesman (SOS), which again, is in-genre, but here's the thing....the SOS's elixirs actually work. In essence, the SOS is an alchemist making magic potions. There are no other examples or mentions of magic anywhere in the book. As I mentioned, I'm not sure what game Mr. Hunt wanted to make. A serious western genre, a parody, or a fantasy-western?

A supplement released 3 additional classes: Gambler, Preacher, and Lawman, but I have not reviewed it.

The rest of the book is pretty standard RPG fare. Combat, gear, town creation, loot tables (which show the D&D pedigree) and the like. The NPC opponents section has another curious inclusion. Not one stat for Indians (although they are in the encounter tables), but there are stats for berserkers. Huh? None of it is really worthy of mention.

The Nitty Gritty Total Page Count: 96 Pages Character Creation: 17 Pages Game Mechanics: 5 Pages Everything Else: 74 Pages

Judgement: Despite my confusion at the given character classes, if you love Basic D&D, then you really owe it to yourself to pick this up on .pdf (it's only a buck ninety-nine!). It's a fun read and it wears it parentage proudly.



Rating:
[4 of 5 Stars!]
pixel_trans.gif
Tall Tales BX Wild West RPG
Publisher: Mark Hunt
by Eric F. [Verified Purchaser]
Date Added: 08/24/2019 00:54:37

"Have you ever wished to ride in the old west? To be part of the thrilling days of yesteryear? Well, this is your chance. Well, not you but a pretend you, a character you portray while you play the game. Just as an Actor would play a part in a Western Movie, you play a character set in the Old west. Your character is in a game world that is both a historical setting and a fantasy setting at the same time, with its legends and tall tales mixed with the finest traditional Spaghetti Westerns. As a Character in this world you can perform deeds of valor, riches, ruin and redemption. You as the player may find the game world is both familiar and foreign at the same time, raw, savage and waiting to be tamed." This game brings home the feel of the old West hard & dangerous the way the West should be. I bought this game last night because Tall Tails B/X Wild West was on sale for $1.99! Mark Hunt quietly develops games & supplements by himself without Kickstarter or much fanfare. But don't let that fool you Mark has been a veteran designer of the game industry for many years. This brings me to Tall Tails B/X Wild West this game clocks in at around ninety six pages. I've been friends with Mark Hunt for many years now but its time to hit the back paths of gunslingers, low-down desperadoes, singing cowboys or snake oil salesmen which are the actual PC classes of this low down twisted game of gun fights, exploration, & there's a feel of the Old West Pulps here. The rpg system is primed to B/X OSR Dungeons & Dragons purely. There's just enough material here to give the players & the DM enough to get started in their own version of the Old West. Lots of good use of public domain Old Western artwork & the layout is readable very nicely done for the eyes. The game is very much in the cut & dry B/X Dungeons & Dragons style.

Tall Tails B/X Wild West covers everything from designing a home base domain town or location to a wild west ranch spread very important aspect for adventurers, outlaws, & Northern green horns; "More than just a collection of ramshackle buildings where dusty cowboys blew off steam before getting back on the trail, or a backdrop to a show down, towns in the Old West played in important part in developing the frontier. Towns served as transport waypoints, financial hubs, communication centers, and helped provide goods, serves, and entertainment" Hunt understands the importance of having the PC's party stretch into their element. Case in point is the adversaries section here's one of the most dangerous foes a group of PC's can run across an NPC gun fighter; "Legendary Gunman This is one of the many deadly gunmen that roamed the old west. "Human Gunslinger: HD 6; AC 0; Atk 2 weapon (1d8); Move 120’; Save 13; AL N; XP 750; Special: +2 to hit in in a showdown. +6 initiative. " Everything here is easily understood & applable to both OSR & old school games. This is very important for DM's looking to add elements of the Old West to their games. But there's additional material to go with Tall Tales BX Wild West RPG New classes is a 'pay what you want' add on for Tall Tails B/X Wild West. Its seven essential pages of PC classes that adds in three new classes: the Gambler, the Preacher and the lawman. These are solid classes that any fan of the Western genre knows exactly what these classes can do & how to put them to use as a player or dungeon master. This is an OSR system like B/X Essentials by Gavin Norman & like Norman's systems BX Wild West RPG New classes is a core add on to have. This is a must pdf if you intend to run this system. Already I can hear the laughter but if we want to add in D&D elements its gonna be an issue? What if Frank Mentzer did all of the hard work for you and all of the heavy lifting?! Not only can you use B/X Essentials but you could with a bit of old school effort grab your trusty Dungeons & Dragons Rules Cyclopedia there's all the monsters you'll ever need! Aaron Allston, & Frank Mentzer have done all of the heavy lifting for you & with the Dungeons & Dragons Rules Cyclopedia you've got years of Old West campaign play.

Now I've heard from different folks that many of these OSR retroclone system are not OGL well Tall Tails B/X Wild West isn't one of those; "All artwork, proper names, logos, and presentation are product identity. The names “Tall Tales” and “B/X Western Tall Tales” are product identity. All text not declared as Open Game Content is product identity. DESIGNATION OF OPEN GAME CONTENT All text and tables in the following sections are Open Game Content: ability scores, sequence of play, adventuring rules, basic combat procedure, other combat issues, standard combat charts, potions. OPEN GAME LICENSE Version 1.0a" Which means that already outfits like Surreal Estate Games have created basic Wild West adventures titles like Tumbleweed Tales Volume 1 by Robert Garitta fills that gap nicely. We'll be reviewing this set of adventures soon enough. But your ready to Country & Western your way across the B/X West! But this isn't the only Basic Dungeons & Dragons style OSR options which applies to Tall Tails B/X Wild West. There's also Dark Dungeons by Blacky the Blackball which can be used with Tall Tails B/X Wild West. These two used together allow the dungeon master to give a much more OSR feel to their Wild West adventures and includes the rules for Spelljammer style ships! Because of the way that Tall Tails B/X Wild West is set up its a solid OSR Wild West tool kit that provides the DM & his or her players with a solid Wild West game. The clean design & layout are a hall mark of OSR design Mark Hunt has a winner on his hands like his own version of the Gang Busters Rpg. Grab Tall Tails B/X Wild West while you can! Eric Fabiaschi Sword & Stitchery blog Want More original OSR content? Subscribe to https://swordsandstitchery.blogspot.com



Rating:
[5 of 5 Stars!]
pixel_trans.gif
Displaying 1 to 2 (of 2 reviews) Result Pages:  1 
pixel_trans.gif
pixel_trans.gif Back pixel_trans.gif
0 items
 Gift Certificates