A fantastic book containing many (but not all) official rotes from 1st - 3rd edition. It gets 4 stars from me because while the artwork and the job on the book is absolutely amazing, it leaves out the Masters of the Art book that is 3rd edition.
While the Masters of the Art book focuses on Sphere scores of 6+, the translation for Sphere's at 6+ would've made a fantastic 'final chapter' or 'last bit of information'. Adding in the 'Masters of the Art' information would have gained 5 stars from me.
Edit: (Seems I can't directly reply to your statement so will just edit this)
There were a few rotes that I had not seen from some of the miscellanious books. I also noticed that many rotes simply noted a page reference and no description what so ever of what the rote did, while other rotes gave full descriptions as well as references for what book they were from.
I'll make a list in my spare time and (probably this weekend) update this post again with Rotes that I've noticed are missing / not in here. I would say easily 90% of them are, but the lack of descriptions would make them a bit more... difficult... to look into.
As it pertains to 'Masters of the Art', there aren't many Rotes in the book. I know and acknowledge that. However I wasn't looking for 'rotes' from Masters of the Art. My above states this: "the translation for Sphere's at 6+ would've made a fantastic 'final chapter' or 'last bit of information' "
So like in M20th chapter 10's section where you go into detail of every sphere's 1-5, a good final chapter would've been nice to see the Masters section where they cover the 'Arch-Spheres', aka Translated sphere levels 6-10.
|