While I like the concept, the author incentivizes being more descript in attacks by rewarding players with a mechanical advantage and while a d4 isn't gamebreaking, it shows the author lacks the fundemental understanding of the bounded accuracy concept making this an unbalanced mess.

HOWEVER you should ask yourself this: is it fun? By all means, this seems like (for your players) it would be VERY fun. If you want combat to run a little faster, and grant players an edge, then this will quite likely spice up your table in a really good way. My rating represents the use of this product at ALL tables, but it's up to the DM to determine if it would be good for THEIR table.

This is a nice simple piece to add to your campaign for a bit more "hurrah!" in combat. This inspires something that could even get your wizard in the action as a last ditch effort to save the day "heroically" when he's out of spells, cornered, and you just need that defining moment to amp up your tales at the tavern. I've personally tweeked the charts at times to use skills instead of attacks but they're originally implied for combat. I recommend this for those who want just a little extra icing in your combat cakes or back pocket...