This product is well thought-out and very organized. 5e is seriously lacking in good Alchemy rules, and I almost always play an alchemist of some kind (Or, before this, I WANTED to) without having to use the UA Artificer class.

The creator thought of everything necessary without overcomplicating things. While I'm not a believer in certain races being able to produce better alchemical products simply by being that race, it's an interesting concept to build lore off of.

There are so many interesting things you can make with this, and it gives good ideas for what else you might be able to think up. For the price, this is a steal, and I think everyone should give these mechanics a try.

Very well done!

PRAISE- Organized, Well thought out, Informed and Useful CRITICISM- As I said above, not a fan of race favorism, but once again this could be for lore and fluff reasons.

This alchemy system is really fleshed out and amazing. Definitely worth the $1 cost! Any improvement would be to provide a larger list of effect types that can be integrated into alchemy, but the system is flexible enough that a PC and DM could work together to implement any sort of custom effect.

Would love to see the blacksmith guide given a similar level of attention to detail, and even other guides for the other artisan tools!

For a long time I had felt that dnd was lacking a good crafting system and this just fixes it. everything felt professionally written. I would love to see a piece on an improved smithing system and maybe even magical item creation. looking forward to your next project!