While the content of the player's guide is excellent (I love all Greyhawk material), I was very disappointed in the "physical" quality of this scan. I purchased the same product several years ago from Paizo when it was first made available, and I purchased this copy to perform a comparison, hoping that Wizards of the Coast had updated the OCR. Sadly, this looks like the exact same file, right down to what looks like a crease or pencil mark on the table of contents on page 7, and a black blot on page 71; the only change in this more recent edition appears to be the addition of a more thorough set of PDF bookmarks.
While I love the older edition stuff for its thoroughness and depth of detail, I doubt I will be purchasing any of the WotC/TSR 1e or 2e stuff until the quality improves – 4 stars for content,0 stars for scan quality
|