To me, a good GM screen helps significantly reduce the need for the GM to review the rule book for commonly occurring events/situations in a game.
Sadly, this set of inserts only scratches the surface of the amount of rules that could come up in a game session of Numenera.
There are four pages for the GM.
Page 1 hits the core rule about Task Difficulty, Distances, basic weapons and armor.
Page 2 talks about the "special rolls" a player can get should their d20 roll certain numbers.
Page 3 hits recovery roll times and damage from hazards
Page 4 replicates the cypher list.
For those who have read the core book you know there are lots of information Chapter 8 about modifiers to Tasks. Items like lighting, gravity. As well as details around tasks like healing. Ruless that could easily be summarized and put on the GM screen.
There is lots of "white space" on pages 2 and 3 and would be a welcome space for many rule elements seen in Chapter 8 of the Core Rule Book. Rules that don't even make it into the Player's guide (that's a different issue all together), but cover the majority of situations that could arise in a game.
In the end, I penciled in what was missing and making my own screen, using this one as the chassis. But I would have liked more in here detailing the information in Chapter 8 - a section have to keep referring to as a game session goes along.
I suspect that the lack of core elements may have been an intentional choice, with the idea that Numenera is to be a fast play system, but the point behind Chapter 8 is giving guidelines on how to handle so many different aspects of play that can come up, from lighting to gravity, that it feels like that chapter 8 needs more exposure either in the GM Screen or in the Player's Guide (preferably both).
I also would have liked a layered PDF in such that the background art on the GM screens could be suppressed to provide a cleaner space to work from.
Still, for $2 it is hard to rate it low and is the only reason I did not give this a two star rating.
And since the Game License prevents someone else from creating a better screen (as the table data is proprietary) I can only hope that the makers of this one take the opportunity to improve upon the design before they throw money in making their own hard copy screen.
|