One Page Dungeon Compendium: 2016 Edition

Overall, thumbs up. The price is nice, too.

These dungeons, graphically, come in a variety of styles. Fonts are sometimes literal (though clearly) printed handwriting. Maps are sometimes on grids, sometimes hexcrawls, sometimes side views (e.g., Ben Gibson's "The Outsider's Son") and sometimes drawn without grids. The descriptions are the length to fit into the margins. One dungeon is a wizard's lab, another an abandoned city and interspersed are traditional dungeon crawls. One dungeon lacks a map, purely theatre of the mind.

To be clear, the formatting and page layout varies from page-to-page. This is because the editor received these as is, and had to incorporate them into one document without the budget for someone to standardize these. Furthermore, doing so would have removed the whimsical feel. I really enjoy seeing the different styles the various GMs used when creating these.

If you want fully-formed and fleshed-out adventures with long story arcs, look...See more elsewhere. However, if you are able to fill in the blanks (e.g., Edward Lockheart's "Death and the Dandy", requires one to realize the priest is mobilzing their flock to assault a den of iniquity) and ad lib a bit, these are wonderful for inserting quickly into adventures. In particular, I anticipate using some of these as useful backup dungeons or encounters when your party decides that they don't want to do the thing they were supposed to do (this happened to me recently), and you want to provide a stopgap encounter or adventure instead of saying "Well, ok, let's reconvene next week after I figure out what to do."

I'm disappointed that you've gone to a flat price on this rather than "pay what you want."