Solid, original slasher-style set-up. Not as good as some that Slasher Flick has producted but its probably simpler to run. The maps are high quality and reuseable (especially the asylum) and the killer is unique.

The only things against it are the art (minoi quibble) and the decision to 'limit' the number of characters to 6 because of, presumably, the size of the boat.

Personally I'd just stick 8 to 12 on a yacht or a flying boat to get to the island and then let loose with that body count; the more the bloodier. :)

Pros: A fully realized "movie" adventure for Slasher Flick, if you want to run the game but don't feel comfortable making your own. A lot of nice little plot elements, and options for twisting the movie around to your pleasure, either because you don't care for the default, or because you would like to re use it.

Cons: Again, the art is a strike against it. My initial thoughts for Horror Island were higher before I read Bloodbath Hotel, which I feel eclipses it.

Overall: It is a nice adventure, feeling familiar without feeling like a complete ripoff of anything. That said, if you must buy just one Slasher Flick adventure, Bloodbath Hotel is the better of the two. However, if you like Slasher Flick and can buy both, this is still a worthy purchase.